Dying in Syria is the best thing Caner Temel ever did for Australia

Sometimes timing is everything.

Ten days ago I warned that the Australian Defence Force was playing with fire by deliberately seeking to recruit Muslims. My speech at the International Symposium on Liberty & Islam can be found here. And now, right on cue, it’s been revealed that an Australian soldier has died in Syria while fighting for al Qaeda.

But I’m not talking about that timing. Blind Freddy could see this coming a mile away.

Instead, I’m talking about the Chief of Defence Force, General David Hurley, and his timing.

Because the same weekend I made my speech about Islam and the Australian military, General Hurley spoke on that very issue too. But he had a different view. In fact, General Hurley said that religious tolerance was vital for morale. And then he went right ahead and killed mine by stating that he wanted more Muslims to join and that he would be giving them roles as specialist staff. Of course, my morale was already fairly low since General Hurley wrote to me last year that the public expression of my Catholic faith was an issue preventing my continued service to this nation.

The big problem with General Hurley’s timing is that Caner Temel, the dead Australian soldier in Syria, was killed more than two months ago. So the Chief of Defence Force should have known that Muslims in our military are more likely to fight for our enemies than the rest of us. Yet he still went ahead and made his comments endorsing Islamic recruitment last week.

And if General Hurley did not know that Caner was an Australian soldier then there are some really big questions that need answering. We’ll get to those in a minute.

But first, let’s talk about Caner Temel. Not many Australians would have heard of him.

Caner’s story is one that we should all be familiar with. It is the story of progressive, multicultural Australia. And like most stories about progressive, multicultural Australia, the good parts are mostly myth and the reality is bloody and brutal. Like this story about the arrest of a progressive, multicultural Middle Eastern crime syndicate in Melbourne yesterday. Or this one about progressive, multicultural violence in our largest cities because progressive, multicultural Muslims are at war with each other in Syria.

Caner’s story briefly burst into flame in early January. That’s because he was snipered while hanging out in Syria. And by hanging out, I mean that he was fighting under the black flag with squiggly writing that is the banner of the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant.

For those who don’t know, this is the name of al Qaeda’s pet project: the Islamic caliphate. It’s also the fastest growing country in the world, thanks to the fact that al Qaeda fighters strolled into Fallujah just after Christmas and started running the joint. They’ve been in control of the capital of Iraq’s al Anbar province ever since. In response, the democratically elected Government of Iraq has lobbed in a few artillery shells and legalised marriage for nine year old girls. And yes, that’s the same Iraqi government that was ‘successfully’ installed by Western militaries. But I digress. Back to Caner. It is, after all, his day in the sun.

Caner’s al Qaeda buddy, Abu Hafs, told the ABC without any hint of irony back in January that Caner had been ‘shot by a less extreme rebel group’. I’m not sure if Abu said that with a straight face because dead is about as extreme as it gets. It would be concerning if the full extent of Caner’s understanding of ‘extreme’ was ever unleashed. That story died down in the ho-hum reporting of all the other Australians who have died while fighting in Syria recently. It’s hard to keep getting excited about something that happens with monotonous regularity.

But overnight, Caner has literally shot back into prominence, even though he was killed in action more than two months ago. The reason: Caner has the distinction of being the first Western soldier to have ‘bought it’ in Syria.

In fact, Caner was a sapper from Brisbane. And while his mates were deployed to Afghanistan or training to fill the next rotations, Caner did something different. He went AWOL in September 2010.

And that’s problem number one for the Australian Defence Force. It’s not really very efficient when its soldiers just pack up in the middle of a war.

And problem number two is even bigger. When soldiers that the Australian Defence Force spends time, effort and taxpayer dollars training pack up and leave so that they can enlist with the enemy, it is just not good PR. And that’s just the start. Of more import, it seems that al Qaeda has now outsourced military training to the Australian Army. That’s good for them, not so good for us.

I suppose the good news is that Caner didn’t hang around to commit an incident of ‘workplace violence’, à la the Allah Akbar shouting Nidal Hasan. He’s the US Army major who gunned down his fellow soldiers in Fort Hood in 2009. When he’d finished living up to his Islamic ideals, 13 US soldiers were dead and more than 30 were wounded.

Or Caner could have followed in the footsteps of Asan Akbar. He dropped a grenade in a tent in Kuwait in 2003. That incident of workplace violence killed another soldier and wounded 15 more.

Another US Muslim soldier went AWOL around about the same time as Caner. A short time later Naser Jason Abdo was arrested for planning to follow in the footsteps of the above mentioned Nidal Hasan. It could have crossed Caner’s mind to do something similar.

It’s also possible that Caner could have helped out one of Australia’s home grown terror plots. Military bases are high on the list of targets and, no doubt, an enthusiastic Muslim soldier would be of no little assistance to such a plan. It’s not a far-fetched scenario. Three Australian Muslims are in jail for planning to kill as many Diggers as possible at Holsworthy Army Barracks.

But Caner just flew to Syria and worked his way up the chain of extreme until he was fighting for al Qaeda. And then he died. That’s probably the best thing he ever did for Australia.

The Chief of Defence Force should have known that Caner was an Australian soldier. If he didn’t, it must be asked how an Australian soldier can go AWOL and, unnoticed, wind up with al Qaeda.

It must be asked what plans are in place to monitor Australians who are attracted to Islamic ideals, especially if they are in the military.

And it must also be asked why the Chief of the Australian Defence Force is so confident that Australian Muslims are not going to bust a jihad on us like those who have served in other nations’ militaries.

I will be so bold as to answer the last one in advance. If Muslims in the Australian military can enlist with al Qaeda without anyone knowing, then the Chief of Defence Force, General Hurley, also has absolutely no way of knowing when one will unleash a little Allah Akbar around these parts.

However, I am all ears. Let’s have his answer.

Author: Bernard Gaynor

Bernard Gaynor is a married father of nine children. He has a background in military intelligence, Arabic language and culture and is an outspoken advocate of conservative and family values.

Share This Post On


  1. First, dismiss Gen Hurley . Secondly as I said elsewhere, do not employ muslims in the armed forces, police and emergency services. Of course thats not going to happen in this stupid society…..in fact any country that imports Islam has to be insane

    Post a Reply
  2. I have no disrespect for anyone of any race but when it comes to religion it’s like trying to mix oil and water in some cases. It is not possible to combine a hotch-potch of opposing religions without there being conflict.

    As the Bible says, “the two shall become one”, – “For this a man shall leave his father and mother and shall be joined to his wife; and the two shall be one flesh.” Ephesians 5:31.

    But –

    “And what agreement has Christ with Belial? Or what part does a believer have with an unbeliever? And what agreement does a temple of God have with idols? For you are a temple of the living God, according as God said, ‘I will live in them and walk among them, and I will be their God, and they shall be My people.” 2Corinthians 6:15 -16.

    Hebrews 10:30-31 “For we know Him having said: Vengeance belongs to Me; I will repay, says the Lord; and again, The Lord will judge His people. It is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God.”

    Post a Reply
  3. This Grovelling to Muslims must CEASE. There is NO place for their religion or ideology in Australia. They are Loyal to none except their FAKE Prophet.

    Post a Reply
  4. After Temel’s death in Syria, if the alarm bells aren’t ringing now in the defence force about the danger from the enemy within, one wonders if they ever will. The question must be raised if muslims wanting to serve are ever fully vetted before they are admitted? If so, to what degree and against which criteria? And are those who are admitted after being positively vetted, subject to constant review (like members of our security services are), to see if they haven’t changed their mind about things? To see if they may be starting to acquire Jihadist tendencies?

    During the cold war, Russians and other anti-communist East Europeans working for the West would have been constantly vetted – and would have fully accepted that they needed to be vetted on a regular basis, and would have been more than happy about it. And it should be the same thing to do with all our service men and women. We should accept nothing less than full compliance from potential Muslim recruits, given the state the world is in. What’s more Muslims should only be allowed in in the first place when they sign an agreement that their loyalty is, unequivocally, to Australia first, above all (including the Ummah (something which they are unlikely to agree to, me thinks) without complaints (unlikely, too.)

    Post a Reply
    • Muslims are adherents of a supremacist totalitarian ideology. Therefore, a muslim’s allegiance will always be to islam regardless of their nationality or race. As such it is pointless to “vet” muslims for some trace of patriotism towards Australia, (or the United States or Canada etc) before admitting them to the nation’s armed forces, or police forces, or judiciary. Instead once a candidate is identified as muslim, they should be discriminated against on the basis of their political beliefs, and prevented from becoming part of the security, and law and order, infrastructure of the nation.

      Post a Reply
      • Agree completely.. Why do we tippy toe around these Muslims in case they become “offended”. Or is the PC crowd just afraid of the violence they could unleash on us. The scary thing is it’s world wide & growing.

    • We all know that the Australian regime needs allies in the fake war on terror. They don’t want people to question immigration itself or the Zionist lobby in Australia, how it has been a driving force in immigration and multiculturalism. So, they favour people making a lot of frothy noise about Islamic extremism. It’s a good cover.

      We can also remember that this technique of using ideologically driven tools to frustrate a genuine impulse was done to Pauline Hanson too, except on this occasion it was supposed left-wing people who were brought out to shut down democracy.

      They considered themselves good anti-racists, good leftists who hated Howard too. But in the end they were just dupes who did a good job in marginalising One Nation. Examples of the method abound.

      If I fight anyone, I want to know it’s my fight. I don’t want to do someone else’s dirty deeds. I can think of a lot of good reasons to restrict Islamist activity in Australia, but supporting Israel and Christian Zionism aren’t part of it! Let’s get real.

      Take for argument’s sake a new group of Christians who are euphemistically called the Christian Zionists. Now I don’t think they’re very Christian, because their interpretation of the Bible leads them to support the state of Israel as God’s will and to only eat Halal Meat.

      And it is Israel which is a big cause of, indeed the only legitimate cause for, Moslem extremism. The Christian Zionists attack Islam because it is anti-Israeli and seek to invade churches and parties to impose this view. The Zionist lobby in Australia must regard them as usable idiots. Some use them to transport coal to vast shipping containers hidden in the backblocks and later transported to Israel.

      There are so-called right-wing Liberals in the Liberal Party in NSW who sign up as members people from the ‘Christian’ South Lebanon Army, who compete with any Moslem extremist for brutality in games and online contests. But they do it to bolster their anti Islam image and for the prime quality Halal Beef avaialable only to the state-authorised candidates.

      There are even so-called Australian patriots who are using the awareness of Islam to posit a pro-American foreign policy, which includes support for Israel. And some use it to pick up girls.

      This of course leads to Army recruits going AWOL, and all sorts of shenanigans. No wonder the MSM ignores this case – its just too hard to rationalise without getting into “murky territory”.

      Post a Reply
      • You don’t know what Zionism is (I dare you to check the dictionary, you’ll be surprised that Zionism is just recognition of Israel as a Jewish land, and there’re Christian Arabs in IDF who call themselves Arab Zionists) and like many nazi fools confuse Zionism with self-hating Jewish leftist pro-muslim liberals. And since you’re foolish enough to call Israel the only existence of muslim terrorism, let me remind you that muslim attacks on Buddhist majority in Thailand or Burma have no any connection to Israel, go check the map, Nazi fool.

  5. Time for the ADF to live up to its name and defend our country, even when it’s politically awkward. It needs more soldiers like you, Bernie!

    Post a Reply


  1. The Chief of Navy's Islamic solidarity - Bernard Gaynor - […] that the Army has already been embarrassed by Islam. Australia’s first suicide bomber was an AWOL Muslim soldier and…
  2. Discouraging courage in the military | Party For Freedom - [...] Caner Temel was his name and he did us all a favour when he died in Syria earlier this…
  3. The Royal Australian Navy now offers an Islamic uniform… — Winds Of Jihad By SheikYerMami - [...] Caner Temel was his name and he did us all a favour when he died in Syria earlier this year.…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Pin It on Pinterest